# The MailerLite alternative we built for ourselves. We paid $69 a month. Now we pay $15.

Mailpuff is a WordPress plugin for newsletters, sign-up forms and emails that send themselves, with no price per subscriber. We paid MailerLite $69 a month at 8,000 subscribers. Today we have over 15,000 contacts on Mailpuff, and sending through PostShiba costs us $15 a month.

## What you pay in a year (MailerLite Comfort, paid yearly, checked 5 November 2026)

| Subscribers | MailerLite | Mailpuff (PostShiba bill) |
| --- | --- | --- |
| 1,000 | $205 | $60 |
| 10,000 | $961 | $180 |
| 50,000 | $3,445 | $180 |

Mailpuff: your PostShiba bill. Mailpuff Pro is a fixed price and is not in this table.

## Why people pick Mailpuff over MailerLite

- **Your list grows. Your bill doesn’t.** At 10,000 subscribers, MailerLite costs $961 a year. Sending with PostShiba costs $180. You keep $781 a year, about $65 every month, before Mailpuff Pro’s fixed price.
- **Pay once for automations.** Our first 200 customers pay once for Mailpuff Pro on up to 10 sites, with updates for life. MailerLite sends a new bill every year for as long as you stay.
- **We made this exact move.** PlugPress paid MailerLite $69 a month at 8,000 subscribers. Today we email more than 15,000 contacts from Mailpuff for $15 a month.

## Mailpuff and MailerLite, side by side

| | MailerLite | Mailpuff |
| --- | --- | --- |
| Price at 10,000 subscribers | $80.10 a month on Comfort, paid yearly ($961 a year) | PostShiba at $15 a month ($180 a year). Mailpuff Pro is a fixed price on top: $89 once in the lifetime deal, or from $49 a year. |
| Price per subscriber | Yes. The bill rises with your list. | No. No limit on subscribers. |
| Free plan | 250 subscribers and 2,500 emails a month since 16 June 2026 (it was 500) | No subscriber limit. Emails that send themselves come with Pro. |
| Where your list lives | MailerLite’s servers, in the EU | Your own WordPress database |
| Emails that send themselves | Comfort: 50 automations | Mailpuff Pro: $89 once for 10 sites |
| Sending | Built in | Your sending service: PostShiba, Amazon SES, Resend or SMTP |
| AI agents | Official MCP server. It can send on paid plans. | Claude, ChatGPT, Cursor and Codex. Sending to your list stays off until you allow it. |

## Why people leave MailerLite

> "Today, I discovered that ML had (yet again) reduced the number of subscribers allowed for a free account." (Trustpilot review by a charity volunteer, August 2026, https://www.trustpilot.com/review/mailerlite.com?stars=1&stars=2&page=2)

> "Our account got frozen in the middle of a campaign with chat support also blocked 7 days ago." (Trustpilot review, October 2026, https://www.trustpilot.com/review/mailerlite.com?stars=1&stars=2)

> "We paid for the Pro version which is $50 LESS for an entire year than what we’ve been paying for MailerLite with our 27,000+ subscribers MONTHLY" (WordPress.org review, January 2026, https://wordpress.org/support/topic/my-favorite-plugin-of-2025/)

## What MailerLite does better

- **Sending is built in.** No sending service to set up. Comfort sends up to 10 times your subscriber tier each month.
- **Websites and landing pages.** MailerLite includes a website and landing page builder, from one page on Free to unlimited on Power.
- **Live chat support.** The Power plan includes 24/7 live chat.

## Move your list

1. In MailerLite, go to Subscribers and select everyone, including unsubscribed people.
2. Click Set columns and add Groups and your fields. Then click Actions and export a CSV.
3. In Mailpuff, go to Subscribers, then Import, and drop in the file. Groups become tags, and unsubscribes stay unsubscribed.

Export guide: https://www.mailerlite.com/help/how-to-export-subscribers

## Questions about MailerLite

**Is MailerLite still free?** Yes, for up to 250 subscribers and 2,500 emails a month. The free plan shrank on 16 June 2026 from 500 subscribers and 12,000 emails. Over 250, sending and automations pause.

**How much does MailerLite cost?** Comfort is $19 a month at 1,000 subscribers, or $205.20 a year paid yearly. It is $89 a month at 10,000 and $319 a month at 50,000. Checked 5 November 2026.

**Can MailerLite’s MCP server send my emails?** On paid plans, yes. On the free plan, MCP access is limited and can’t send. In Mailpuff, sending to your list stays off for AI agents until you turn it on.

**Will my groups come with me?** Yes. Mailpuff reads MailerLite’s export and turns its Groups column into tags.

## Sources

- MailerLite pricing: https://www.mailerlite.com/pricing
- MailerLite free plan update: https://www.mailerlite.com/help/free-plan-update-faq
- Export subscribers: https://www.mailerlite.com/help/how-to-export-subscribers
- MailerLite MCP server: https://developers.mailerlite.com/mcp
- MailerLite website builder: https://www.mailerlite.com/features/website-builder
- Trustpilot reviews: https://www.trustpilot.com/review/mailerlite.com?stars=1&stars=2
- WordPress.org review: https://wordpress.org/support/topic/my-favorite-plugin-of-2025/
