The MailerLite alternative we built for ourselves. We paid $69 a month. Now we pay $15.

Mailpuff is a WordPress plugin for newsletters, sign-up forms and emails that send themselves, with no price per subscriber. We paid MailerLite $69 a month at 8,000 subscribers. Today we have over 15,000 contacts on Mailpuff, and sending through PostShiba costs us $15 a month.

What you pay in a yearMailerLite Comfort, paid yearly
1,000 subscribers
MailerLite$205 a year
Mailpuff$60 a year
10,000 subscribers
MailerLite$961 a year
Mailpuff$180 a year
50,000 subscribers
MailerLite$3,445 a year
Mailpuff$180 a year

Checked 5 November 2026. Mailpuff: your PostShiba bill. Mailpuff Pro is a fixed price and is not in this chart.

Why people pick Mailpuff over MailerLite.

Three reasons, with the real numbers behind them.

Your list grows. Your bill doesn’t.

At 10,000 subscribers, MailerLite costs $961 a year. Sending with PostShiba costs $180. You keep $781 a year, about $65 every month, before Mailpuff Pro’s fixed price.

Pay once for automations.

Our first 200 customers pay once for Mailpuff Pro on up to 10 sites, with updates for life. MailerLite sends a new bill every year for as long as you stay.

We made this exact move.

PlugPress paid MailerLite $69 a month at 8,000 subscribers. Today we email more than 15,000 contacts from Mailpuff for $15 a month.

Mailpuff and MailerLite, side by side.

Checked 5 November 2026, from each company's own pages.

MailerLiteMailpuff
Price at 10,000 subscribers$80.10 a month on Comfort, paid yearly ($961 a year)PostShiba at $15 a month ($180 a year). Mailpuff Pro is a fixed price on top: $89 once in the lifetime deal, or from $49 a year.
Price per subscriberYes. The bill rises with your list.No. No limit on subscribers.
Free plan250 subscribers and 2,500 emails a month since 16 June 2026 (it was 500)No subscriber limit. Emails that send themselves come with Pro.
Where your list livesMailerLite’s servers, in the EUYour own WordPress database
Emails that send themselvesComfort: 50 automationsMailpuff Pro: $89 once for 10 sites
SendingBuilt inYour sending service: PostShiba, Amazon SES, Resend or SMTP
AI agentsOfficial MCP server. It can send on paid plans.Claude, ChatGPT, Cursor and Codex. Sending to your list stays off until you allow it.

Why people leave MailerLite.

In their own words, from public reviews and forums.

“Today, I discovered that ML had (yet again) reduced the number of subscribers allowed for a free account.”

Trustpilot review by a charity volunteer, August 2026

“Our account got frozen in the middle of a campaign with chat support also blocked 7 days ago.”

Trustpilot review, October 2026

“We paid for the Pro version which is $50 LESS for an entire year than what we’ve been paying for MailerLite with our 27,000+ subscribers MONTHLY”

WordPress.org review, January 2026

What MailerLite does better.

Every tool has strengths. If one of these matters most to you, MailerLite may be the better pick.

  • Sending is built in. No sending service to set up. Comfort sends up to 10 times your subscriber tier each month.
  • Websites and landing pages. MailerLite includes a website and landing page builder, from one page on Free to unlimited on Power.
  • Live chat support. The Power plan includes 24/7 live chat.

Move your list in about 15 minutes.

Your subscribers, tags and unsubscribes come with you.

  1. 1

    In MailerLite, go to Subscribers and select everyone, including unsubscribed people.

  2. 2

    Click Set columns and add Groups and your fields. Then click Actions and export a CSV.

  3. 3

    In Mailpuff, go to Subscribers, then Import, and drop in the file. Groups become tags, and unsubscribes stay unsubscribed.

Questions about MailerLite.

Can’t find yours? Email us

Is MailerLite still free?

Yes, for up to 250 subscribers and 2,500 emails a month. The free plan shrank on 16 June 2026 from 500 subscribers and 12,000 emails. Over 250, sending and automations pause.

How much does MailerLite cost?

Comfort is $19 a month at 1,000 subscribers, or $205.20 a year paid yearly. It is $89 a month at 10,000 and $319 a month at 50,000. Checked 5 November 2026.

Can MailerLite’s MCP server send my emails?

On paid plans, yes. On the free plan, MCP access is limited and can’t send. In Mailpuff, sending to your list stays off for AI agents until you turn it on.

Will my groups come with me?

Yes. Mailpuff reads MailerLite’s export and turns its Groups column into tags.

Bring your MailerLite list to WordPress.

Export a file from MailerLite, then import it in Mailpuff. No price per subscriber.