Your readers live on your site.
On Substack, followers can’t be exported. In Mailpuff, every reader sits in your own WordPress database, ready whenever you need them.
Substack is free to publish and keeps 10% when readers pay. Mailpuff is a WordPress plugin: your posts, your list and your sign-up forms stay on your own site, with no price per subscriber. You pay for Mailpuff Pro and for sending. Mailpuff does not sell paid subscriptions.
Three reasons, with the real numbers behind them.
On Substack, followers can’t be exported. In Mailpuff, every reader sits in your own WordPress database, ready whenever you need them.
Substack charges $50 to put your publication on your own domain. Mailpuff runs on the site and domain you already have.
Claude, ChatGPT, Cursor or Codex can draft emails and send you a test, right in your WordPress. You press send.
Checked 5 November 2026, from each company's own pages.
In their own words, from public reviews and forums.
“Substack removed my publication, citing its Spam & Phishing policy.”
“You also can’t export followers like you can with subscribers.”
“I would need to pay Substack over $25,000 a year in fees”
Every tool has strengths. If one of these matters most to you, Substack may be the better pick.
Your readers come with you. Substack’s export has no tags, and Mailpuff tells you if the file doesn’t say who turned off emails.
In Substack, open your Subscribers page and scroll to All subscribers.
Click the three dots above the list, choose Export, and pick all columns.
In Mailpuff, go to Subscribers, then Import, and drop in the file. The columns are matched for you.
Can’t find yours? Email us
Yes, to publish, at any list size. If you charge readers, Substack keeps 10% of each payment and Stripe takes its card fees.
10% of each subscription payment. Stripe also charges 2.9% plus 30 cents per US card payment and 0.7% for recurring billing. Checked 5 November 2026.
Substack is easiest if you want its reader network and paid subscriptions. WordPress with Mailpuff fits if you want your newsletter, your list and your site in one place you own, with no cut of your income.
Yes, as a CSV at any time. The file has plan type but no names, and followers can’t be exported. Readers who pay through Apple’s in-app billing can’t be moved.
They can read it, not run it. Substack’s MCP server is read only and open to Bestseller publications only.
Export a file from Substack, then import it in Mailpuff. No price per subscriber.